| Page | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
CAROL C. LAM
United States Attorney
SANJAY BHANDARI
Assistant U.S. Attorney
California State Bar No. 181920
JASON A. FORGE
Assistant U.S. Attorney
California State Bar No. 181542
PHILLIP L. B. HALPERN
Assistant U.S. Attorney
California State Bar No. 133370
Federal Office Building
880 Front Street, Room 6293
San Diego, California 92101-8893
Attorneys for Plaintiff
United States of America
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
Plaintiff,
v.
Defendant.
Criminal Case No. 05cr2137-LAB
PLEA AGREEMENT
IT IS HEREBY AGREED between the plaintiff, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, through its
counsel, Carol C. Lam, United States Attorney, and Sanjay Bhandari, Jason A. Forge,
and Philip L.B. Halpern, Assistant United States Attorneys, and defendant, RANDALL
HAROLD CUNNINGHAM, with the advice and consent of K. Lee Blalack and Mark Holscher,
counsel for defendant, as follows:
//
//
//
Defendant agrees to waive Indictment and plead guilty to a two-count Information charging defendant with one count of Conspiracy in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 371, and one count of Tax Evasion in violation of Title 26, United States Code, Section 7201.
Defendant understands that the offenses to which he is pleading guilty have the following elements:
Defendant has fully discussed the facts of this case with defense counsel. Defendant has committed each of the elements of the crimes, and admits that there is a factual basis for this guilty plea. The following facts are true and undisputed:
The “Arlington Condominium” is a condominium located at 1211 South Eads Street, Arlington, Virginia that defendant owned from on or about December 3, 2001, until on or about March 8, 2004,.
The “Del Mar Home” is a house located at 13832 Mercado Drive, Del Mar, California that defendant owned from on or about January 20, 1988, until on or about November 20, 2003. In or about late November 2003, defendant sold the Del Mar Home to 1523 New Hampshire Ave., LLC, and purchased a house located at 7094 Via del Charro, Rancho Santa Fe, California (the “Rancho Santa Fe Home”).
“Top Gun Enterprises, Inc.” is a California corporation based in San Diego County, California that defendant owned and operated at all times material to the Information. As of the date of this agreement, Top Gun Enterprises, Inc.’s office address was the Rancho Santa Fe Home.
The “Kelly C” is a 65-foot yacht of which defendant was the legal owner at all times material to the Information.
“Coconspirator No. 1” is an individual who was the majority owner of a defense contractor at all times material to the Information.
“Coconspirator No. 2” is an individual who was the majority owner of a defense contractor at all times material to the Information.
The “Buoy Toy” is a 42-foot yacht that Coconspirator No. 2 purchased on or about August 30, 2002. From in or about fall 2002,
Def. Initials _____ 3 05cr2137-LABthrough in or about summer 2005, the boat (officially renamed the “Duke-Stir” on January 21, 2003) was docked in defendant’s slip at the Capital Yacht Club, 1000 Water Street, SW, Washington, D.C.
“1523 New Hampshire Ave., LLC” is a Nevada domestic limited liability company of which Coconspirator No. 2 was the managing member at all times material to the Information.
“Coconspirator No. 3” is an individual who controlled a financial company located in Rosedale, New York at all times material to the Information.
“Coconspirator No. 4” is an individual who was the president of a mortgage company located in Greenvale, New York at all times material to the Information.
Beginning no later than the year 2000, and continuing through about June 2005, within the Southern District of California and elsewhere, defendant conspired and agreed with Coconspirator No. 1, Coconspirator No. 2, Coconspirator No. 3, Coconspirator No. 4, and others (hereinafter collectively referred as the “Coconspirators”) to commit the following offenses against the United States:
scheme to defraud the United States of its right to defendant’s honest services, including its right to his conscientious, loyal, faithful, disinterested, unbiased service, to be performed free of deceit, undue influence, conflict of interest, self-enrichment, self-dealing, concealment, bribery, fraud, and corruption, and, in executing said scheme, to cause matters and things to be sent and delivered by the United States Postal Service and private and commercial interstate carriers, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1346 and 1341;
payments and benefits received by defendant, in violation of Title 26, United States Code, Section 7201.
In furtherance of this conspiracy, defendant and his Coconspirators used the following methods and means, among others:
which defendant did because of his receipt of the above-described payments and benefits;
payment for the purchase of the defendant’s Arlington condominium; and
In furtherance of this conspiracy, and to effect the objects thereof, on or about the dates set forth below, defendant committed and caused to be committed, within the Southern District of California, and elsewhere, the following overt acts:
defendant deposited into his personal bank account at Congressional Federal Credit Union in Washington, D.C.;
a furniture store for a leather sofa and a sleigh-style bed, which were delivered to defendant;
(Form 1040) over $500,000 in illicit payments and benefits that he received during the 2003 tax year;
On or about April 15, 2005, within the Southern District of California, defendant willfully evaded and defeated his lawful income tax due and owing for the calendar year 2004, by. preparing, signing and filing with the Internal Revenue Service under penalty of perjury, a false and fraudulent joint U.S. Individual Income Tax Return (2004
Def. Initials _____ 16 05cr2137-LABForm 1040), in which he falsely stated that his joint taxable income was $121,079, and that he was due a refund of $8,504, whereas, as he then knew, his joint taxable income was at least $1,215,458, and there was a joint taxable income due and owing of at least $385,077.
Defendant understands that the crimes to which defendant is pleading guilty carry the following penalties:
Defendant understands that failure to comply with any of the conditions of supervised release may result in revocation of supervised release, requiring defendant to serve in prison all or part of the term of supervised release.
Defendant further understands that by pleading guilty, defendant may become ineligible for federal benefits.
Def. Initials _____ 17 05cr2137-LABDefendant agrees to forfeit all of his right, title, and community property interest in the following assets, which constitute or were derived from proceeds traceable to violations 18 U.S.C. §§ 201, 1341, 1343, and 1346 or which are substitute assets:
To the extent necessary, defendant further agrees not to contest the administrative forfeiture of the foregoing assets. Further, defendant knowingly and voluntarily waives any rights and defenses he may have under the Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution to the forfeiture of the above-described property in this proceeding or any related civil proceeding.
Defendant understands that this guilty plea waives the right to:
The Government represents that any information establishing the factual innocence of defendant known to the undersigned prosecutor in. this case has been turned over to defendant. The Government will continue to provide such information establishing the factual innocence of defendant.
Defendant understands that if this case proceeded to trial, the Government would be required to provide impeachment information relating to any informants or other witnesses. In addition, if defendant raised an affirmative defense, the Government would be required to provide information in its possession that supports such a defense. Defendant acknowledges, however, that by pleading guilty defendant will not be provided this information, if any, and Defendant also waives the right to this information. Finally, defendant agrees not to attempt to withdraw the guilty plea or to file a collateral attack based on the existence of this information.
Defendant represents that:
This plea agreement is limited to the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of California, and cannot bind any other federal, state, or local prosecuting, administrative, or regulatory authorities, although the Government will bring this plea agreement to the attention of other authorities if requested by defendant.
Defendant understands the sentence imposed will be based on the factors set forth in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a). Defendant understands further that in imposing the sentence, the sentencing judge must consult the United States Sentencing Guidelines (Guidelines) and take them into account. Defendant has discussed the Guidelines with defense counsel and understands that the Guidelines are only advisory, not mandatory, and the court may impose a sentence more severe or less severe than otherwise applicable under the Guidelines, up to the maximum in the statutes of conviction. Defendant understands further that the sentence cannot be determined until a presentence report has been prepared by the U.S. Probation Office and defense counsel and the Government have had an opportunity to review and challenge the presentence report. Nothing in this plea agreement shall be construed
Def. Initials _____ 22 05cr2137-LABas limiting the Government’s duty to provide complete and accurate facts to the district court and the U.S. Probation Office.
This plea agreement is made pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(c)(1)(B). Defendant understands that the sentence is within the sole discretion of the sentencing judge. The Government has not made and will not make any representation as to what sentence defendant will receive. Defendant understands that the sentencing judge may impose the maximum sentence provided by statute, and is also aware that any estimate of the probable sentence by defense counsel is a prediction, not a promise, and is not binding on the Court. Likewise, the recommendation made by the Government is not binding on the Court, and it is uncertain at this time what defendant’s sentence will be. Defendant also has been advised and understands that if the sentencing judge does not follow any of the parties’ sentencing recommendations, defendant nevertheless has no right to withdraw the plea.
Although the parties understand that the Guidelines are only advisory and just one of the factors the court will consider under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) in imposing a sentence, the parties will jointly recommend that the Court utilize the November 2004 Guideline Manual and the following Base Offense Levels, Specific Offense Characteristics, and Adjustments set forth in the Guidelines:
Def. Initials _____ 23 05cr2137-LABThe above calculations result in a Total Offense Level of 33 and a guideline range of 135 to 168 months (assuming that the defendant falls within Criminal History Category I).
The parties agree to recommend jointly that if the sentence imposed on Count One is less than the total punishment, then the sentence imposed on Count Two shall run consecutively to the extent necessary to produce a combined sentence equal to the total punishment, as mandated by Guidelines § 5G1.2(d).
Notwithstanding paragraph A.3 above, the Government will not recommend any adjustment for Acceptance of Responsibilitity if defendant:
The parties agree that both the Government and the defendant are free to argue for or against any upward or downward adjustments (other than arguing against those listed above), including any adjustments based upon aggravating role, mitigating role, or obstructing and impeding the administration of justice.
There is no agreement as to defendant’s Criminal History Category.
The parties agree that both the Government and defendant are free to argue for or against any upward or downward departures.
The parties agree that the facts in the “factual basis” section of this agreement are true, and may be considered as “relevant conduct” under USSG § 1B1.3 and as the nature and circumstances of the offense under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) (1).
Def. Initials _____ 25 05cr2137-LABThe parties agree that the Government will recommend that defendant be sentenced within the advisory Guidelines range as calculated by the Government pursuant to this agreement. However, if the Court adopts an offense level or downward adjustment or departure (other than a downward departure pursuant to the Government’s recommendation under 18 U.S.C. § 3553, or § 5K1.1 of the Sentencing Guidelines, as described in Section XIV below) below the Government’s recommendations in this plea agreement, the Government will recommend a sentence as near as possible to what the sentence would have been if the Government’s recommendations had been followed.
The parties will jointly recommend that defendant pay a special assessment in the amount of $200.00 to be paid forthwith at time of sentencing. The special assessment shall be paid through the office of the Clerk of the District Court by bank or cashier’s check or money order made payable to the “Clerk, United States District Court.”
Fine. The parties have reached no agreement on the appropriate fine, if any, to be imposed upon defendant.
Any fine shall be paid through the Office of the Clerk of the District Court by bank or cashier’s check or money order made payable to the “Clerk, United States District Court.”
Defendant agrees that, before sentencing, defendant shall provide to the United States, under penalty of perjury, a financial disclosure form listing all his assets and financial interests valued at more than $1,000. Defendant understands that these assets and financial interests include all assets and financial interests in which
Def. Initials _____ 26 05cr2137-LABdefendant has an interest (or had an interest subsequent to December 31, 1999), direct or indirect, whether held in defendant’s own name or in the name of another, in any property, real or personal. Defendant shall also identify all assets valued at more than $5,000 which have been transferred to third parties since January 1, 2000, including the location of the assets and the identity of the third party(ies).
The parties will jointly recommend that as a condition of probation or supervised release, defendant will notify the Collections Unit, United States Attorney’s Office, of any interest in property obtained, directly or indirectly, including any interest obtained under any other name, or entity, including a trust, partnership or corporation after the execution of this plea agreement until the fine or restitution is paid in full.
The parties will also jointly recommend that as a condition of probation or supervised release, defendant will notify the Collections Unit, United States Attorney’s Office, before defendant transfers any interest in property owned directly or indirectly by defendant, including any interest held or owned under any other name or entity, including trusts, partnerships and/or corporations.
In exchange for the Government’s concessions in this plea agreement, defendant waives, to the full extent of the law, any right to appeal or to collaterally attack the conviction and sentence, including any restitution order, unless the court imposes a custodial sentence greater than the high end of the Guidelines range (or statutory. mandatory minimum term, if applicable) recommended by the Def. Initials _____ 27 05cr2137-LAB
Government pursuant to this plea agreement at the time of sentencing. If the custodial sentence is greater than the high end of that range, defendant may appeal, but the Government will be free to support on appeal the sentence actually imposed. If defendant believes the Government’s recommendation is not in accord with this plea agreement, defendant will object at the time of sentencing; otherwise the objection will be deemed waived.
This plea agreement is based on the understanding that, prior to defendant’s sentencing in this case, defendant has not committed or been arrested for any offense not known to the Government prior to defendant’s sentencing. This plea agreement is further based on the understanding that defendant will commit no additional criminal conduct before sentencing. If defendant engages in additional criminal conduct during this period, or breaches any of the terms of any agreement with the Government, the Government will not be bound by the recommendations in this plea agreement, and may recommend any lawful sentence. In addition, at its option, the Government may move to set aside the plea.
The Defendant agrees to work with the Internal Revenue Service to file corrected income tax returns, including but not limited to individual income tax returns for the years 2000 through 2004, correctly with accurate and truthful information, pay any tax
Def. Initials _____ 28 05cr2137-LABliability due thereupon, including penalties and interest, and file all future tax returns as required truthfully and honestly.
The Defendant agrees that he will pay in full his outstanding tax liability once assessed, including penalties and interest, or enter into an installment payment plan with the Collection Division of the Internal Revenue Service. If he enters into any such agreement, he shall make timely payments and shall abide by the terms of such agreement.
Defendant has expressed a desire to provide substantial assistance to the Government in the investigation and prosecution of others, after entering his guilty plea. The Government has made no evaluation whether the cooperation, if any, will be “substantial,” or whether it will merit a downward departure from the Sentencing Guidelines.
Defendant agrees to be interviewed by federal and state law enforcement agents and attorneys and to tell everything defendant knows about every person involved presently or in the past directly or indirectly in the acts and offenses identified in the Information in this case, and all other acts and offenses related thereto, as well as any other criminal offenses. Defendant also agrees to produce all documents and other evidence in defendant’s possession or control related to these offenses.
Defendant agrees not to do any undercover work or tape record any conversations or gather evidence unless instructed by the agent assigned to defendant. Defendant can be prosecuted for any criminal activity undertaken without instructions.
Def. Initials _____ 29 05cr2137-LABDefendant agrees to provide statements under penalty of perjury and to testify before any federal or state grand jury, and at any pretrial, trial or post-trial proceedings. Defendant will provide complete, truthful and accurate information and testimony. Defendant agrees to submit to a polygraph examination to test the truthfulness of defendant’s statements, upon request by the Government.
The Government agrees that, if defendant fully complies with this plea agreement, it will not make use of any statements made by defendant during the period of post-plea cooperation in any further prosecution of defendant for any offense, or in defendant’s sentencing as provided in Guideline § 1B1.8. If defendant does not fully comply with this plea agreement, all statements made by defendant before, during and after this plea agreement, and any leads or evidence derived from such statements can be used against defendant and are admissible in court.
Statements made by defendant pursuant to this plea agreement are not statements “made in the course of any proceedings under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure” and are not statements “made in the course of plea discussions.”
The determination as to whether defendant has provided substantial assistance is solely for United States Attorney’s Office to make. If the United States Attorney’s Office decides that defendant has provided substantial assistance, and has fully complied with this plea agreement, it will file a motion for a downward departure under 18 U.S.C. § 3553, or § 5K1.1 of the Sentencing Guidelines. Defendant acknowledges that even if the Government makes a motion, the Court may reject the Government’s motion and
Def. Initials _____ 30 05cr2137-LABrecommendation for departure and refuse to depart downward, and defendant would not be allowed to withdraw his guilty plea.
If the United States Attorney’s Office decides to make a substantial assistance motion, it will inform the sentencing judge of: (1) this plea agreement; (2) the nature and extent of defendant’s activities in this case; (3) the full nature and extent of defendant’s cooperation with the Government and the date when such cooperation commenced; and (4) all information in the possession of the Government relevant to sentencing.
If defendant provides materially false, incomplete, or misleading testimony or information, or breaches this plea agreement in any other way, the Government may prosecute defendant in connection with all federal criminal violations of which it is aware, including false statements, perjury and obstruction of justice, and defendant’s sentencing guidelines may be adjusted for making false statements (e.g., § 301.1 and § 3E1.1). In addition, the Government may move to set aside this plea agreement, and prosecute defendant on any charges, including those in the Information in this case. However, if the Government elects not to set aside the plea agreement, defendant agrees that the Government may recommend any lawful sentence without restriction by this plea agreement. Any prosecution and sentence resulting from a breach of this plea agreement may be based on information provided by defendant.
This plea agreement embodies the entire plea agreement between the parties and supersedes any other plea agreement, written or oral.
Def. Initials _____ 31 05cr2137-LABNo modification of this plea agreement shall be effective unless in writing signed by all parties.
By signing this plea agreement, defendant certifies that defendant has read all 33 pages of this agreement. Defendant has discussed the terms of this plea agreement with defense counsel and fully understands its meaning and effect.
Def. Initials _____ 32 05cr2137-LABDefendant has consulted with counsel and is satisfied with counsel’s representation.
CAROL C. LAM
United States Attorney
SANJAY BHANDARI
Assistant U.S. Attorney
JASON A. FORGE
Assistant U.S. Attorney
PHILLIP L.B. HALPERN
Assistant U.S. Attorney
K. LEE BLALACK
Attorney for Defendant
MARK HOLSCHER
Attorney for Defendant
IN ADDITION TO THE FOREGOING PROVISIONS TO WHICH I AGREE, I SWEAR UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY THAT THE FACTS IN THE “FACTUAL BASIS” PARAGRAPH ABOVE ARE TRUE.
RANDALL H. CUNNINGHAM
Defendant